Instead of using the Sum function on your Auto Renew Total, try the SumIf function.
If looks like the Unique Values you want to test are already present in your PO and Vendor column, so your formula could be:
=SumIf(PO and Vendor, PO and Vendor,1)This translates into something like, "Compare the current row's value for
PO and Vendor column value against
all the values in the
PO and Vendor column and any time a match appears, increment the count by 1.
For more info:
Here's a link to the SumIf function