Global Storage

Global Storage Forum

Connect, collaborate, and stay informed with insights from across Storage

 View Only
Expand all | Collapse all

IBM Power Systems vs. Ryzen 9 Laptops: Which is Better for Enterprise Workloads?

  • 1.  IBM Power Systems vs. Ryzen 9 Laptops: Which is Better for Enterprise Workloads?

    Posted Thu September 21, 2023 03:34 AM

    Greetings IBM Community,

    I hope this message finds you all in good health. I find myself at a crossroads in my decision-making process regarding the choice of hardware for enterprise workloads, and I would greatly appreciate your insights and experiences on this matter.

    The Dilemma:

    As I embark on a critical project for our enterprise, I'm facing the challenging decision of selecting the right hardware to support our workloads. The two options on my radar are IBM Power Systems and Ryzen 9 laptops, each with its own set of advantages and considerations.

    IBM Power Systems:

    Pros:

    Established track record in enterprise environments.

    Robust scalability and reliability.

    Extensive support for virtualization and mission-critical applications.

    Strong security features.

    Cons:

    Typically higher upfront costs.

    May require specialized expertise for management and maintenance.

    Ryzen 9 Laptops:

    Pros:

    More cost-effective for initial investments.

    Modern AMD Ryzen 9 processors offer impressive performance.

    Portable and versatile for a variety of tasks.

    Easier to manage and maintain.

    Cons:

    May lack the scalability and reliability required for certain enterprise workloads.

    Security concerns in comparison to enterprise-class systems.

    Seeking Guidance:

    Given these considerations, I'm eager to hear from those who have faced a similar decision or have hands-on experience with either option. Are there specific factors or criteria that should weigh heavily in the decision-making process? What have been your experiences with IBM Power Systems or Ryzen 9 laptops in enterprise environments?

    Moreover, are there any real-world examples or use cases that have guided your choices in selecting one over the other? Your insights, anecdotes, and recommendations will be invaluable in helping me make an informed decision for our enterprise.

    Conclusion:

    I understand that there may not be a one-size-fits-all answer, but I'm hopeful that the collective wisdom of this community can shed light on the factors that should influence this crucial decision. Thank you in advance for sharing your knowledge and experiences in the realm of enterprise workloads, and for helping me navigate this pivotal choice between IBM Power Systems and Ryzen 9 laptops.



    ------------------------------
    Melissa Hankins
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: IBM Power Systems vs. Ryzen 9 Laptops: Which is Better for Enterprise Workloads?

    Posted Sun September 24, 2023 07:05 AM

    Hi Melissa,

    that's comparing apples and oranges ... most of todays 'enterprise' workloads performance requirements tend to be RAM and bus / IO centric rather than processor centric. So just look at the effective sustained RAM and bus throughput of a Power10 Server as compared to a ???laptop??? .... and the answer is right in front of you.

    To get you started on system sizing and what really counts for enterprise class systems you might find the following presentation quite usefull:

    Power10_Performance_Quick_Start_Guides.pdf (ibm.com)

    Have fun sizing ;-)

    Axe



    ------------------------------
    Axel Lachmann
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: IBM Power Systems vs. Ryzen 9 Laptops: Which is Better for Enterprise Workloads?

    Posted Mon October 02, 2023 02:53 AM

    Your insights and experiences are sought after in my decision between IBM Power Systems and Ryzen 9 laptops for our enterprise workloads. The pros and cons have been meticulously weighed, but real-world examples and use cases would be invaluable. Your collective wisdom can illuminate this crucial decision. Many thanks for your contributions.



    ------------------------------
    jhoney bairstow
    ------------------------------