Hi TJ.
From my experience it's likely something with the synchNode command. Below is a link with the syntax you should be following.
pic.dhe.ibm.com/infocenter/wasinfo/v7r0/...You access the remote host where Node 2 resides.
Issue the synchNode command from the BIN directory for the profile.
Enter the username and password (unless you put it in the command line)
The synchNode command should provide feedback to the console indicating any errors.
If you encounter issues, please copy and paste the console commands and output (removing sensative information.) as well as the relavent information from the nodeagent systemOut.log
Good luck,
Erik