Current ABM and IBM MaaS360 Admin. Ran into the same issues you were.
I had 2 iPod Touch 6th generation, iOS 12.5.7 16 GB devices that were "re-enrolling" themselves constantly, drove me mad.
These devices did not have profile removal options like other iOS.
I would remove control and hide just like your client was doing Bryn. The devices would show up as Pending Control Removal and I would erase the device, not from IBM MaaS but from the device itself. After booting the device would prompt the same start-up questions (you can skip the Apple ID prompt by going to "forgot iCloud" and selecting "Set up later in Settings") I would then click "Don't Transfer App & Data" to ensure that nothing was left over to re-enroll the device. I would then be met with the same screen "Remote Management" and a message that the device would be managed by my organization. At the same time the device would populate back into my MaaS360 with an active status (and consuming another license).
This happened because of one main factor; when the device connected to the internet (or via iTunes) the device was being checked by apple server to see if it is a managed device. Usually a good thing, however if the device is still in your ABM Apple Business Manager as a device. You will keep "boot looping" just with extra steps.
To fix your problem
1) Unenroll normally from the MDM (Remove Control first then Hide)
2) Navigate to your ABM and select Devices, then the device you want to remove, then in the top right corner, there are three tiny dots in a circle. Click on this and select Release from Organization.
3) Preform a Device Erase from the device itself.
When the device boots back up, there should be no prompting of Remote Management when completing the initial device setup.
You can verify the device is removed by checking Devices> Device Inventory> Managed State > Pending Control Removal & InActive.
Hope this help; I know a little late I was looking for the answer myself when I forgot about releasing the device.
------------------------------
Brandon Walton
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: Tue February 11, 2020 06:01 AM
From: Bryn Abbott
Subject: Apple devices re-enrolling themselves
Hi,
One of our clients has an issue whereby they remove control from devices, factory reset and wipe the device the, without any input, the device re-enrolls itself and they receive a notification.
If they were using DEP I would have somewhere to look but they don't.
Anyone had this, know of a resolution?
Thanks in advance.
------------------------------
Bryn Abbott
------------------------------