Hi Emily, unfortunately getting stuck in what I call "MDM limbo" happens sometimes even on brand new out of the box devices. Here are the steps that work for us to get the phone out of limbo:
Open itunes
Connect phone to PC
Power on phone
While connected, press and hold POWER and HOME buttons until itunes logo appears (not apple)
Via itunes prompt, choose RESTORE
Via itunes prompt, choose RESTORE AND UPDATE (this puts phone in recovery mode)
Watch for prompts via itunes, and process can take up to 20 minutes but phone should be back to OEM settings
Disconnect from itunes, reboot and try MDM setup again
Julie
------------------------------
Julie Liddle
------------------------------